7 Major Gift Fundraising Challenges — And How to Move Through Them

Let's be honest: major gift fundraising is hard. Not because you're doing it wrong, and not because your donors are difficult. It's hard because the work is genuinely complex — it requires emotional intelligence, patience, courage, and strategy, often all at once.

But here's what I want you to know: the challenges you're facing are predictable. I've seen them across hundreds of conversations with fundraisers and nonprofit leaders over the past six years of coaching. The same seven obstacles come up again and again, regardless of organization size, sector, or budget.

And every single one of them is moveable.

This isn't about having a perfect plan. It's about knowing what you're dealing with — and having a clear-headed response ready when it shows up.

1. "Our prospect pipeline feels empty."

The feeling: Panic. Where do we even start? We've already asked everyone we know.

Here's the shift I want you to make: stop looking for wealthy people, and start looking for loyal ones.

Your best future major donors are almost certainly already in your database. They're giving $500 or $1,000 a year. They come to your events. They respond to your emails. They've been quietly showing up for years — and nobody has ever asked them for more.

I coached a fundraiser at a girls' school in the Bronx who had a donor giving $1,000 a year for fifteen years. That donor had never been asked for more. She hadn't moved away from the organization — she'd just never been seen as a major gift prospect. One phone call, one genuine question about the school's values, and she called back within fifteen minutes to make a $100,000 gift. She now gives $200,000 annually.

Wealth capacity is not the same as relationship capacity. Before you run a wealth screening or chase new names, look at who's already there. Who shows up? Who responds? Who gives consistently, even at a modest level? That loyalty is telling you something. Start there.

2. "I can't get a meeting."

The feeling: Frustration. I've left voicemails and sent emails. Nothing.

If you keep hitting a wall with a prospect, the first question to ask is: does this person even know enough about our work to want a conversation? Sometimes silence isn't avoidance — it's unfamiliarity.

If the relationship is genuinely warm but the meeting isn't happening, try a different door. Think about who in your world — or theirs — already has a relationship with this person. A peer: a college friend, a fellow alumni, someone from their club, a colleague from a board they serve on together. An influential introduction from someone who runs in the same circles almost always opens a door that your emails can't. Not because you're not credible — but because people say yes to people they know.

You can also try shifting the ask entirely. Instead of "I'd love to give you an update," try "I'm working through a strategic question and would love your perspective." People who won't make time for a pitch will often make time to share their expertise. And once you're in the room, you can let the relationship do what it does.

What I'd caution against: piling on more outreach without changing the approach. If the same message isn't working, more of it won't fix that.

3. "I'm terrified of asking for a large amount."

The feeling: Fear. What if they get upset? What if they say no? Saying $100,000 out loud feels impossible.

This is one of the most common things I hear from fundraisers — and it's not a character flaw. It's a language gap.

The fear usually comes from a misunderstanding of what the ask actually is. If you walk into the room thinking I'm about to take something from this person, of course it feels awful. But if you walk in thinking I'm about to offer this person an opportunity to do something meaningful with their resources, the whole conversation shifts.

You're not asking for $100,000. You're inviting them to fund the thing they told you they care about most.

And then there's the practical side: the number feels scary because it's unfamiliar. Practice saying it out loud. Role-play it with a colleague. The more you say it, the more it sounds like a real number instead of an impossible one.

Barbara Mari was a Principal Gifts Advisor at St. Jude Children's Research Hospital when we worked together. She told me she used to feel like donors were rejecting her — personally. That belief was getting in the way of everything. Once she shifted her understanding of what a donor conversation actually is — not a pitch, not a transaction, but an invitation — she closed a $750,000 gift from a brand-new donor.

Confidence doesn't come first. Language and practice come first. Confidence follows.

4. "My donor has gone silent."

The feeling: Confusion and dread. We had such a good meeting. I sent a proposal. And now — nothing.

First: silence is almost never the same as no. It usually means life got busy. Donors are human, and humans get distracted.

What I'd suggest before you follow up at all: get curious. Do you actually know what's going on in their life right now? Because if you don't, that's your starting point — not another email nudging them toward the gift.

Adele is an experienced fundraiser at Covenant House BC. As she moved toward year-end, she hadn't heard back from one of her most consistent donors. She'd already reached out multiple times. She felt pushy. She was starting to assume he just wasn't giving this year.

When we got on a coaching call, I asked her: "So what's going on with him right now?"

She didn't know.

We pulled up his LinkedIn profile right then. He'd just launched a new initiative within his company — it was right there, publicly visible. I told her to reach out and mention it.

She sent a simple message: "Congrats — I'd love to hear more about what you're working on!"

That one message — no mention of the gift, no year-end appeal, just a genuine acknowledgment of something happening in his life — led to a $10,000 gift.

Your job isn't to push. It's to stay present in a way that reminds the donor you value the relationship — not just the transaction. And staying present starts with actually knowing what's going on in their world.

5. "My board isn't helping."

The feeling: Exasperation. I ask them to help with fundraising. They nod and then nothing happens.

Most board members want to help. They're just scared — and unclear on exactly what you need.

"Help with fundraising" is not a clear ask. It's too big, too vague, and for most board members, too scary. The fundraisers I've seen get the most out of their boards are the ones who make it specific and make it easy.

Give your board members real choices: Would you be willing to host a small gathering for 8-10 people who care about this work? Would you make five thank-you calls to loyal donors this month? Would you look at this list of prospects and tell me who you know? Let them pick what feels manageable for them.

Then give them exactly what they need to do it — the email template, the call script, the key talking points. Remove every obstacle you possibly can. And when a board member follows through, celebrate it. Publicly. That kind of recognition is contagious.

6. "I'm overwhelmed and there's no time for major gifts."

The feeling: Burnout. I'm one person doing everything. Major gifts keeps getting pushed to "when things slow down."

Here's what I know: things don't slow down. And "when things slow down" never comes.

What changes the situation isn't more time — it's more focus. And focus means making a deliberate decision about where your energy goes.

Start with the Top 10 donors for you to focus on NOW. These are the donors and prospects most likely to make a significant gift in the next 12-18 months, or people who need early moves, touches from certain people. Set your strategy and then map out the steps. We aren't talking about focusing on the "Top 100" donors. You can't focus on 100 households. Then build your Next 20 to focus on for the next month - your touchpoints, what they need to be invited closer. The Next 20 are the relationships that need development before they're ready for a meaningful conversation.

That's your portfolio. That's where your major gift energy lives. And here, we are thinking of a portfolio of between 100 and 150 households. The right size to create meaningful actions, conversations, and moves. 

Once you have that list, protect time for it. Block it on your calendar the same way you'd block a board meeting. And start asking honestly: what am I doing right now that has a low return on that investment? What could be simplified, delegated, or paused to make room for work that actually moves the needle?

Major gifts almost always has the highest ROI in the building. It deserves the time that reflects that.

7. "My leadership doesn't understand why this takes so long."

The feeling: Misunderstood. They want to see dollars now. But this work takes time, and I can't explain that without sounding like I'm making excuses.

This is a real tension, and it's worth taking seriously — not just as a communication problem, but as a genuine leadership challenge. You need to help your Executive Director or board understand what major gift fundraising actually looks like in motion, before the gifts arrive.

Start by tracking and reporting on the right things. In addition to dollars raised, show: how many new prospects were identified, how many discovery conversations happened, how many proposals were submitted, how many donors moved to the next stage of cultivation. These are the leading indicators of future revenue — and they tell a story that "total amount raised this quarter" can't. And by the way, how is your donor retention coming along? Low retention is a symptom of donor churn - you get them but don't keep them, don't help them feel they belong, that they or their giving matters. 

Then make the case with real numbers. A donor who gives $5,000 this year and is properly cultivated might give $50,000 over the next decade. A gala attendee who gives $250 at the event and never hears from you again is worth exactly $250. Lifetime value changes the math.

And when you do close a major gift, don't just report the number. Tell the story of the twelve months of relationship-building that made it possible. That education helps your leadership understand what they're investing in — and why it's worth the time.

Here's what I want you to hold onto.

Every one of these challenges is solvable. Not perfectly, not overnight — but with clarity, intention, and the right next step.

Major gifts don't have to feel mysterious. They're built through honest conversations, consistent presence, and the courage to invite donors into something bigger than they've imagined for themselves.

If you're sitting with one of these challenges right now and you're not sure what your next move is — that's exactly what I'm here for.

Q: I have donors who've been giving at the same modest level for years. Is it too late to have a different conversation with them?

It's almost never too late — and honestly, those long-loyal donors are often your best major gift opportunity. The fact that someone has given $500 or $1,000 every year for a decade isn't a ceiling. It's a signal. They care about your work deeply enough to keep showing up, year after year, often without being asked for more.

What changes the conversation is a genuine question — not a bigger ask out of nowhere, but real curiosity about what the organization means to them. Why do they give? What do they hope their gift makes possible? That conversation is almost always waiting to happen. You just have to start it.

Q: My leadership keeps asking for major gift results right now. How do I help them understand this work takes time?

Start by showing them what's already moving. Dollars closed is a lagging indicator — by the time the gift arrives, the work is months or years old. So track and report the leading indicators too: discovery conversations started, relationships deepened, proposals submitted, donors moved to the next stage.

Then make the lifetime value case. A donor who gives $2,500 this year and is thoughtfully cultivated may give $25,000 over the next ten years. A donor who gives the same amount and never hears from you again is worth exactly $2,500. When your leadership sees those numbers side by side, the investment in relationship-building stops looking like a slow burn and starts looking like strategy.

— 

Beth Ann Locke is the founder of The Fundraiser Coach and has been an embedded fundraiser for 30+ years and focused on major gifts for 20 years. She coaches major gift fundraisers and nonprofit leaders to build genuine donor relationships and secure transformational gifts. Learn more at thefundraisercoach.com.